J. Budziszewski, author of Pandemic of Lunacy keynote from Touchstone’s 40th Anniversary Conference.

After giving a college lecture on the American Founding one day, I was approached by a baffled student who asked what I had meant when I mentioned the “common good.” None of her government teachers had ever mentioned such a thing, and she had never heard the expression before. All her life, she said, all of her teachers had told her that politics is by definition a pursuit of self-interest. Not that people often do pursue self-interest through political means—obviously true—but that its pursuit was all that politics is.
I was stunned. It wasn’t just that the term “common good” was new to her, although it was. It wasn’t just that she didn’t believe in the common good, although of course she couldn’t have. It was that no matter how I explained it, she was unable to grasp the concept. For her, St. Augustine’s question of how a government is different from a gang of thieves would have been incomprehensible. What else could it be?
It was almost as bizarre an experience as when, after I had lectured for several days on the Summa theologiae, a student asked me whether Thomas Aquinas believed in God.
Now, I am not one of those who think that political and economic life must be based on what New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani has called “the warmth of collectivism.” As William McGurn remarked recently in The Wall Street Journal (“J. D. Vance ‘Fixes’ Capitalism,” August 3, 2026), the opposite of competition isn’t cooperation; it’s collusion. Even Christ’s command to love our neighbors as ourselves presupposes that we love ourselves, instructing us to use this love to measure our treatment of others.
Two cheers, then, for self-interest. The fact is that, in a fallen world, though the supply of virtue may sometimes be a little more and sometimes a little less, there will never be enough of it to run everything on virtue alone. Ancient Sparta tried that. Not only were its notions of virtue abhorrent, not only was Sparta an oppressor, but when abstemious and highly disciplined Spartans were absent from Sparta, their behavior tended to fall to pieces.
Don’t our own constitutional traditions claim that it is possible to channel self-interest itself toward the common good? Well, yes. But if that is our goal, we had better know what we are getting into. It is a lot harder than it sounds. Explaining that is the purpose of this essay.
Shared Loves & Self-Interest
Reflecting on the history of Rome, Augustine explained how the self-interested love of glory, which in reality is a vice, could so closely ape a virtue that the Roman political classes thought it really was one. The reason it could imitate a virtue well enough to fool them is that, although I may have all sorts of other corrupt desires, my love of glory may be stronger still. Thus, just for the sake of being admired by others, I may suppress all those other corrupt desires and perform seemingly public-spirited deeds in the public square. I reform the constitution. Or I fix the aqueducts. Or I beat off an invading army. The underlying idea is that love of glory, which is a vice, may channel and direct even baser motives so that it gives rise to at least some of the behavior that true virtue would produce.



