Michael Root reviews Dmitri Solzhenitsyn’s Reuniting Rome with the Orthodox in First Things

“For anyone wanting to learn more about the present state of Catholic–Orthodox relations, this book is an excellent place to begin.”
Ecumenism has, to put it mildly, stalled. Since the beginning of this century, efforts aimed at bringing about greater unity among the Protestant mainline churches have settled into a friendly mutual indifference. No effective way has been found to involve evangelical Protestants in ecumenical discussions, even when they are interested. Protestant–Catholic dialogues that had achieved agreement on some conceptual theological issues, such as justification, hit a wall when topics related to practice and ecclesiology were taken up. In addition, shifts in the ethical teachings of many mainline Protestant churches in North America and Europe have deepened their separation from Catholicism and limited their dialogue with the Orthodox.
Catholic–Orthodox relations form a partial exception to this assessment. Progress in Catholic–Orthodox dialogue has slowed to a crawl, but not because the issues seem insoluble. East and West have been divided for centuries over the nature of the primacy and authority of the Bishop of Rome as well as the role of the Son in the procession of the Holy Spirit. For the East, the Western idea that the Spirit proceeds from the Father “and the Son” (in Latin, filioque) endangered the unity of the Trinity. That the West added the word filioque to the Nicene Creed was shocking. Over the last fifty years, dialogue between theologians of the two churches has shown real progress on these issues. One might have thought that the millennium-long schism was on the verge of solution. New roadblocks arose, however, as the Orthodox world was upended following the fall of the Soviet empire. Orthodox churches in Eastern Europe sought greater independence from Moscow, an independence Moscow contested. Institutional turmoil ensued. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has only made matters worse.
Dmitri Solzhenitsyn hopes to help break this logjam in his Reuniting Rome with the Orthodox. Solzhenitsyn, grandson of Aleksandr, has written a learned and comprehensive introduction to the history of the Catholic–Orthodox divide and how it might be overcome. This is not a book for specialists only; it is eminently readable, and technical issues are, for the most part, explained well. In addition, the history and theology are presented with remarkable evenhandedness, a virtue not always encountered in discussions of these matters. For anyone wanting to learn more about the present state of Catholic–Orthodox relations, this book is an excellent place to begin...
Read the whole article here.



