Media MentionsAuthor Spotlight

Just Like Us

Patrick J. Deneen’s ‘American Odyssey‘ reviewed in Commonweal

Just Like Us

What’s the point of Great Books? There’s never been a straight answer. Leo Strauss argues that they offer an opportunity for “listening to the conversation among the greatest minds” of history, transmitting timeless wisdom to future generations. Others—including Socrates in Plato’s Republic as well as today’s critics of Eurocentric canons—might strip texts like Homer’s Iliad of the very title of “great book.” In their view, such works glorify violent misdeeds and propagate pernicious values. Some of today’s leading champions of liberal education, such as Purdue’s Melinda Zook, prefer the term “transformative texts” for the books that have changed the world and can still change their readers.

Patrick Deneen’s American Odyssey takes a somewhat different approach to one of the indisputable monuments of the Greco-Roman tradition, Homer’s Odyssey. Here, Odysseus’s epic journey isn’t an opportunity for readers’ self-transformation or even a vehicle for universal insights. Instead, Deneen takes the Odyssey as a sort of mirror for twenty-first-century readers in the United States. They—like Odysseus—are driven by two competing drives: a need for novel adventure and a persistent longing for home. “No ancient story,” Deneen writes, “is as well-matched to our American souls as the Odyssey.”

In the wake of Christopher Nolan’s blockbuster movie adaptation of the Odyssey, this is a good time to reconsider what we’re supposed to get out of great books like Homer’s epic. Do we see our modern American selves reflected in the duplicitous king of Ithaca? Should we even want to? Deneen thinks we should, and he urges us to “gain deeper self-understanding” by studying the “honorary Americans” who populate Homer’s story. Invitations to return to the richness of Homeric poetry are always welcome, but the thesis of Deneen’s book—that there is something particularly American about a three-thousand-year-old poem—risks reducing Homer’s boundless, wine-dark sea to a can of Coke.

Deneen’s argument begins not with Homer but with Alexis de Tocqueville’s Democracy in America. For today’s readers, this nineteenth-century sociological study is best known for its praise of American “associations” and its anxiety about the “tyranny of the majority,” the psychological pressure to conform to prevailing opinion. From among the many topics Tocqueville’s great survey covers, American Odyssey focuses on his assessment of our “national inability to rest satisfied in one’s achievements.” Even though Democracy in America was published nearly two hundred years ago, Deneen argues that its diagnosis of our agitated “restlessness” remains a “central feature of the American character.”

Read the full article here

Recent Articles

A Soviet Handbook for Fighting Totalitarianism

Media Mentions

A Soviet Handbook for Fighting Totalitarianism

Jacob Howland reviews Vladimir Bukovsky's To Build a Castle in Law & Liberty

Read More
Realism and Reunion

Media Mentions

Realism and Reunion

Michael Root reviews Dmitri Solzhenitsyn's Reuniting Rome with the Orthodox in First Things

Read More
Feeding my New Orleans habit

Media MentionsAuthor Spotlight

Feeding my New Orleans habit

Shelton Reed reflects on his love of New Orleans in Portico

Read More

subscribe

to receive updates and special offers from Creed & Culture

Footer Subscription

By submitting this form I confirm that I have read and accept the Privacy Policy.